Showing posts with label DEformers. Show all posts
Showing posts with label DEformers. Show all posts

Monday, August 6, 2012

Education jargon: What ‘no excuses’ and other terms really mean


Posted at 08:00 AM ET, 08/02/2012 (see original post HERE)

By 

This was written by Joanne Yatvin, a vet­eran public school educator, author and past president of the National Council of Teachers of English. She is now teaching part-time at Portland State University.
By Joanne Yatvin
Way back when I was a college student, one of my professors warned the class to avoid using jargon in our papers. By jargon he meant big words of indeterminate meaning. Ever since then I’ve tried to follow his advice in my own writing and to be aware of jargon in the writing of
(© LAUGHING STOCK/CORBIS)
others. But I’ve also come to recognize that there are different kinds of jargon and at least one of them is justifiable. That jargon is a “shorthand” used in the technical literature of specialized fields to refer to complicated entities or processes that readers are already familiar with. By using jargon the writers avoid giving long and unnecessary explanations.
But what about other kinds of jargon? Well, some kinds may not carry much meaning, but they do serve the writers’ purposes. Take, for instance, the stock phrases used in formal or ritualistic communications, such as letters of application or notes of condolence. “Yours truly,” and “May you be comforted” don’t really say anything, but they do convey the message that the writer knows the rules and cares enough to write.
And, of course the whole field of advertising is riddled with jargon intended to impress people about the superiority of various products, while not promising anything so specific that it could trigger a lawsuit. We constantly hear or read such words as, “amazing,” “easy to use,” and “long-lasting.” This jargon often ensnares the gullible among us and even, sometimes, experienced consumers like me.
In addition, there is the jargon used in discussing politics and important public issues. That kind of jargon is not meaningless; it deliberately implies one thing while referring to something very different. In the current presidential race, for example, we hear one side call its candidate is a “job creator” because he headed a business for several years, but in fact his business closed American companies and sent jobs overseas.
From the other side we hear that its candidate wants tax cuts for the “middle class,” but what that term really means is people earning less than $250,000 a year, including the working poor. He uses it to appeal to the majority of people who want to believe they are part of that noble and hard-working layer of society.
Apart from politics, the most contentious public issue today is education. It is a polarized field, where all kinds of governmental bodies, organizations, think tanks, and citizen groups hold strong views about how schools should change or be managed and whether or not it would be better to privatize them altogether. At the same time, most people have little knowledge about the realities of education, basing their opinions on personal experience, their worldviews, and what their leaders tell them. Thus, the flow of jargon is plentiful and forceful, seeking to turn the tide of public opinion irrevocably in a particular direction.
As a life-long educator I can’t keep away from reading and listening to the various arguments about education and noticing the jargon. When I find some bit that seems especially misleading, I want to point it out to others and explain what it really means.
But there is a problem here: I am a partisan, on the side of public schools, career teachers, teachers unions, and progressive education. Although I know that they all have flaws, I still believe they are better intentioned and more often right than the groups that oppose them. So, perhaps it is not surprising that I find very little jargon in their arguments. That means that almost all the examples of misleading jargon I can point to come from the other side. Nevertheless, I will take the leap into ‘Jargonland’ below and hope that readers will see merit in my choices.
.Here are examples of sentences containing misleading jargon (in italics). Following are my explanations of what the jargon really means.
In many states teacher evaluations will now include the results ofvalue-added assessments.
Meaning: Teachers will be judged in part by comparing students’ current test scores to those of the previous year. To what extent the teacher is responsible for the gains—or lack thereof—is debatable.
Our newly published reading program is research-based.
Meaning: Perhaps only one study supports the program’s methods, and that may be a study conducted by the author or publisher. Another possibility is that the program only superficially follows the methodology found effective by many studies.
.
We should be educating the “whole child. ”
Meaning: The writer disapproves of current educational reforms that minimize social, moral, physical, and imaginative learning in favor of a sole focus on academic learning.
All schools in America should be showing high studentachievement.
Meaning: Achievement means only improved test scores, which could be the result of intensive test preparation, student sub-group manipulation, or cheating. Moreover, achievement and learning are not synonymous.
The new Common Core Standards are more rigorous than state standards.
Meaning: The CCSS are more difficult than those of most states, but not necessarily more appropriate for the designated grade levels or more in line with college or workplace expectations.
We are a “ no excuses ” school!
Meaning: The school has a strict set of rules and practices for teachers and students. Those who cannot or will not comply are asked to leave. The system is impractical for large public schools where total conformity cannot be enforced.
A team of experts has reviewed the new standards and found them appropriate for children of this age.
Meaning: The experts selected were college professors, think tank members, and private sector consultants who may never have taught children or spent any time observing in classrooms. Very likely, no practicing teachers were considered “expert” enough to be included in the team.
We need to reform our failing schools .
Meaning: A school’s principal and teachers are to blame for students’ low test scores. They need to be removed or the school should be closed.
States should closely monitor and limit the proliferation of for-profit schools.
Meaning: You can’t trust schools run by businesses.
The Department of Education has given many states NCLB waivers.
Meaning: The DOE has allowed some states to substitute their own plans for school improvement for the requirements of NCLB, as long as those plans are just as demanding or even more so.
I could go on pointing out more examples of misleading jargon in education, but I think there is enough here to reinforce the idea of “Reader beware!” I also suspect I’ve supplied enough fodder for those readers who would disagree with my choices or explanations. If so, in the spirit of this Olympic year, “Let the games begin!”
-0-
Follow The Answer Sheet every day by bookmarkingwww.washingtonpost.com/blogs/answer-sheet .
By   |  08:00 AM ET, 08/02/2012 

Thursday, March 22, 2012

Teacher Turnover Affects All Students' Achievement, Study Indicates

By Stephen Sawchuk on March 21, 2012 12:45 PM posted on http://blogs.edweek.org/edweek/teacherbeat/2012/03/when_teachers_leave_schools_ov.html

When teachers leave schools, overall morale appears to suffer enough that student achievement declines—both for those taught by the departed teachers and by students whose teachers stayed put, concludes a study recently presented at a conference held by the Center for Longitudinal Data in Education Research.

The impact of teacher turnover is one of the teacher-quality topics that's been hard for researchers to get their arms around. The phenomenon of high rates of teacher turnover has certainly been proven to occur in high-poverty schools more than low-poverty ones. The eminently logical assumption has been that such turnover harms student achievement.

But a couple years back, two researchers did an analysis that showed, counter-intuitively, it's actually the less- effective teachers, rather than the more- effective ones, who tend to leave schools with a high concentration of low-achieving, minority students. It raised the question of whether a degree of turnover might be beneficial, since it seemed to purge schools of underperforming teachers.

When reporting on that study, I played devil's advocate by pointing out that it didn't address the cultural impact of having a staff that's always in flux. The recently released CALDER paper suggests I may have been right in probing this question.

Written by the University of Michigan's Matthew Ronfeldt, Stanford University's Susanna Loeb, and the University of Virginia's Jim Wyckoff, the new paper basically picks up on the same question. Even if overall teacher effectiveness stays the same in a school with turnover, it's well documented that turnover hurts staff cohesion and the shared sense of community in schools, the scholars reasoned. Could that have an impact on student achievement, too?

To find out, they looked at a set of New York City test-score data from 4th and 5th graders over the course of eight years. The data were linked to teacher characteristics.
(All the usual caveats about limitations of test scores apply, of course.)

Among their findings:

• For each analysis, students taught by teachers in the same grade-level team in the same school did worse in years where turnover rates were higher, compared with years in which there was less teacher turnover.
• An increase in teacher turnover by 1 standard deviation corresponded with a decrease in math achievement of 2 percent of a standard deviation; students in grade levels with 100 percent turnover were especially affected, with lower test scores by anywhere from 6 percent to 10 percent of a standard deviation based on the content area.
• The effects were seen in both large and small schools, new and old ones.
• The negative effect of turnover on student achievement was larger in schools with more low-achieving and black students.

"Turnover must have an impact beyond simply whether incoming teachers are better than those they replaced—even the teachers outside of this redistribution are somehow harmed by it," the authors conclude. "Though there may be cases where turnover is actually helpful to student achievement, on average, it is harmful."

They authors call for more research to identify the mechanics of the decline—whether a loss of collegiality, or perhaps a loss of institutional knowledge among the staff due to turnover, is the cause of the lower achievement.

Tuesday, February 14, 2012

Closing schools can kill 'heart' of a community, foes say

GENEVA — The bad economy has thrown a wrench in Chuck Wolski's automotive-repair business in rural Geneva.

Some folks who lost their jobs have moved away from the northeastern Seminole County community, taking their cars with them and cutting into Wolski's revenues.

But if the local elementary school is closed, as the School Board in Sanford is talking about, it may be the death knell for his business.

"We've got 45 or 50 teachers and other staff over at that school, and if they close it down, that is going to take 45 or 50 more of my customers," said Wolski, whose reputation for mechanical skills coupled with a convenient location draws school business his way.


If he were a big corporation such as General Electric, closing some little country school wouldn't affect him a bit, Wolski said.

"But it is going to kill us."

Geneva Elementary is first on the list of eight schools the Seminole County School Board has targeted for possible closure in a cost-cutting move designed to bridge a $20 million gap in next school year's budget. The School Board is circling in on perhaps two schools, causing Geneva and others on the list to fight for their survival.

Business income, housing prices and community spirit all are at risk, they say.

Other elementary schools that could be closed, in priority order, are Keeth, Casselberry, Hamilton, Stenstrom, Lake Orienta, Wekiva and Carillon.

Superintendent Bill Vogel on Tuesday will ask the School Board to decide by Feb. 28 whether it intends to close any schools — and if it does, to name them by March 13.

School Board Chairman Tina Calderone said the issue, which has riled thousands of parents across the county, might be put to rest Tuesday. The state Legislature seems on the road toward providing enough funding so schools would not have to be closed, she said, although that is not yet assured.

Still, Calderone and Vogel say that Seminole County "has a school system, not a system of schools." No one is guaranteed to attend a particular school, and despite certain individual characteristics, the schools ultimately are interchangeable, they say.

But those who live and work around the eight schools on the list could not disagree more.

"To take away the school would rip out the heart and soul of our community," said Andy Searles, who has a daughter in second grade at Casselberry Elementary. "New residents won't move in. New businesses won't come in. To close the school would be catastrophic for a community like Casselberry."

continue reading here

Monday, January 30, 2012

Why the Education State of the Union Matters




Posted in the Huffington Post : 01/29/2012 6:25 pm

(Or, A Tale of Two Speeches)

Over at Teacher in a Strange Land, Nancy Flanagan asked, ""Who speaks for public education?"

I'd answer that a lot of people do (for better, and for worse) but we don't all get the same kind of microphone, or the same airtime.

After watching the State of the Union address Tuesday night, I found myself thinking about the differences between President Obama's statements on education and those of California Governor Jerry Brown.

In public statements over the past year, Governor Brown has said what many educators and parents nationwide have been saying for over a decade: that current state and federal education policy has emphasized high-stakes testing so much it has distorted and undermined the learning process. And in his address, he outlined a specific direction for policymakers: that the amount of standardized testing be reduced, that the data be returned to schools more quickly and that more qualitative measures of school performance be developed and used. He ended his education remarks with these words:

The house of education is divided by powerful forces and strong emotions. My role as governor is not to choose sides but to listen, to engage and to lead. I will do that. I embrace both reform and tradition -- not complacency. My hunch is that principals and teachers know the most, but I'll take good ideas from wherever they come.
By contrast, in the State of the Union Tuesday night, President Obama made vague allusions to a few existing K-12 education policies. They include paying teachers to increase test scores ("merit" pay) and encouraging states to seek 'waivers' that exchange freedom from NCLB's impossible requirements for the adoption of the Administration's preferred policies, which are just as strict. Hidden in applause lines aboutrewarding the best teachers and granting flexibility are unproven policies that many researchers and public school stakeholders agree are hurting education.

But, some ask, why does this matter? Neither of these leaders have any direct say over what happens in classrooms. Speaking strictly literally, school systems are typically run by local district officials and school board members (or mayoral appointees... ) overseeing schools, principals and teachers. So why should we care what a president, or even a governor, says or does about schools?

Because aside from the influence and funding at their disposal, their policy advocacy shapes public perceptions of public education, and those perceptions shape our behavior. (They have bigger microphones, and better airtime.)

It pains me to say this, but it's the truth: Most people have no clue what goes on in their local government. Everyone knows who the president is; most people know who their governor is. But how many people can even name their representatives on their town council or school board without a Google search? Of them, how many know what their policy positions are, or how they've voted to spend their neighbors' property taxes? (Answer: Not a whole lot.)

As I talked to Denver voters during our local school board races last fall, it was clear that -- exceptionally involved community members excluded -- most voters were taking their cues on how to vote from what they'd heard about education in the national media. (This is why it's possible for the majority of people toapprove of their local schools and teachers, but believe that public education as a whole is failing.)

So when a governor says he believes principals and teachers know the most about education, and asks for policies that reemphasize teaching and learning instead of testing, that matters. And when a president says he wants teachers to teach with creativity and passion, but uses the influence of the federal government to increase high-stakes testing, that matters too.

For starters, voters who consistently hear positive messages about how schools should be funded, and teachers trusted, are probably going to be more inclined to support policies that fund schools and empower teachers. And when under-informed voters hear misleading statements about "merit" and "flexibility," they're being set up to support policies, at all levels of government, that will hurt schools instead of helping them.

Moreover, when the most powerful and visible leaders promote a vision of schooling that works from the bottom up, they empower the local actors who do the work to do what they think is best. But when those leaders deceive the public, and position themselves as the grantors of "flexibility" and the arbiters of "merit," local stakeholders get stuck dealing with inappropriate (and just plain bad) policy, which can create some pretty toxic circumstances where the rubber meets the road.

Of course, we shouldn't (as one Tweeter accused) "blame the POTUS" entirely for bad things happening in our local schools, nor should we give a governor undue credit if and when his state's schools improve. But high-profile leaders wield a disproportionate amount of power over the circumstances under which public school stakeholders work. And we have every right to demand that they wield that power responsibly.

Follow Sabrina Stevens Shupe on Twitter: www.twitter.com/TeacherSabrina