Showing posts with label huffington post. Show all posts
Showing posts with label huffington post. Show all posts

Tuesday, March 27, 2012

Teach Plus: In Education, Who's Leading Who?

from Education on HuffingtonPost.com

By Marcello Sgambelluri

Earlier this month, I attended the International Summit on the Teaching Profession, where the issue of educational leadership was front and center. This setting seemed a long way from my first grade classroom, but I found many points that resonated within the walls of my school.

A principal should not be the tip of the pyramid in a school, but rather a dot in the middle, said Ziga Turk, the Slovenian Minister of Education. This visual illustrates the principal not as a disseminator of commands in a top-down approach, but rather as a synthesizer, thought partner, and enabler to teachers.

This idea of the principal as part of the community, central but not hierarchical, led to the meat of the discussion: that real instructional leadership in education needs to come first and foremost from teachers. When teachers take the lead, we:

1) Feel valued and empowered.
2) Receive efficient and necessary professional development (after all, who knows what a teacher needs better than a teacher?).
3) See career growth while staying in the classroom.
4) Improve our personal classroom practice through self-reflection, and clarify our craft by teaching it to others.
5) Don't "shut our doors," but rather feel empowered to share our best practices with new teachers who desperately want for it.

In order for teachers to be leaders, we need to be given the time and resources to collaborate with and observe other teachers. We also need to be ready to open up to constructive criticism and open our classroom doors unabashedly to every teacher in the building. The principal must support these teams by providing resources (for example, time and space, professional development on collaboration, and opportunities for relationship building), and facilitate group discussions and sharing of ideas.

Here's one example of what this looks like: In my current school, each grade level's planning times are both staggered and aligned. During contiguous planning times, we can have team meetings; during staggered planning times, we have the option of observing each other teach. This way we, as teachers, can provide feedback to our peers.

We would all love for our principals to be experts of every subject and grade they lead -- and I do believe principals should to be instructors first and foremost -- but to expect them to be experts in science, math, reading, and social studies instruction, in up to six different grades, is not realistic. What is realistic, however, is the goal of building collaborative leadership teams where skilled teachers can share our expertise in our respective fields.

As Minister Bjorklund of Sweden pointed out, when we leave reform up to principals and administrators, we leave it to so few who can aim for change ... and so many who can oppose it. If we are to truly change education, we need to start with the foundation and not the tip of the pyramid; we need to start with ourselves, the teachers.

We are the leaders we have been looking for. Give us the time, the resources, and the framework. After all, no one is more equipped to lead the change in education than teachers.

Marcello Sgambelluri teaches first grade at Community Academy Public Charter School in Washington, D.C. He is currently a Teach Plus Teaching Policy Fellow.

Monday, March 19, 2012

Matthew Resnick: Great Principals: Leaders, Learners, Innovators

from Education on HuffingtonPost.com

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/matthew-resnick/post_3123_b_1348042.html

The age-old question of "What makes a good leader?" is making its latest debut on the education front in New York City. With all the recent developments regarding teacher evaluations, the discussion of principal evaluations has emerged. In order to improve education, every aspect of a school must be addressed -- including the principal. Principals, like any other type of leader, have a lot of responsibilities. The main job of a principal is to ensure that the students in their school are receiving an effective education, and they must do whatever it takes to ensure that that happens -- no excuses.

What are the qualities of a great principal?

1) Providing constructive feedback to teachers

At an event hosted by teacher group Educators 4 Excellence, 64 percent of teachers in the room said that their principals do not provide meaningful feedback. This is a scary statistic. As a student, I am constantly being evaluated and given feedback -- this is how I know where my weaknesses are, and how I can improve. Teachers need the same type of support from principals.

2) Accepting feedback from teachers, administrators, and students

An effective leader must receive feedback from those they are leading -- and respect it. Being a principal should not be a solo job -- every part of the school community needs to speak up, and be heard. A principal needs to take both praise and criticism constructively. If something is going right, build on it. If something is going wrong, find out why, and fix it.

3) Being accessible and consistent

A principal needs to be available to teachers, parents, and students as often as possible. A principal can't spend all their time cooped up in an office, or outside the school building, rather a balance of in the classrooms and in an office. A principal needs to be present to ensure that what is supposed to be happening is happening, and ready to address any concerns that may arise.

4) Facilitating meaningful communication and collaboration between teachers

Communication is a fundamental concept across the board -- from personal things such as relationships to worldwide issues. A school is no exception -- the teachers and administrators must work together to improve classes, and the school as a whole. Students working together is no foreign concept. Group projects, peer tutoring, and other methods of student collaboration have existed for quite a while, and research has shown that this is beneficial for the students. Teachers can learn a lot from each other, even across the disciplines. Mr. Dimitri Saliani, principal of Eleanor Roosevelt High School, recognizes the importance of continued learning, even as an educator: "I pride myself on being a learner, not just an educator. Every teacher is a learner and has obviously enjoyed learning in their lifetime, hence their career choice, so I wondered how else we can learn from one another at ERHS." Mr. Saliani implemented a system that allowed teachers from all disciplines to attend his classroom visits with him -- regardless of the subject. I saw math teachers in my history class, history teachers in my science class, and so on. He concluded by stating, "It has invigorated the faculty and myself to learn from one another, to think about employing new teaching and learning strategies, and opened the door to new opportunities for collaboration." A great principal goes beyond the simple teacher meetings, and creatively develops innovative ways for teachers to collaborate.

5) A constant effort to innovate and improve

A great principal knows that there is always room for improvement. A principal should wake up every morning and ask "How can I make my school better?" Principals need to be creative, and develop unique ways to engage the teachers and students. Principals must be willing to take risks sometimes -- a school cannot be run the same tried-and-true way forever. Evaluators: keep this in mind -- measure a principal not just using pre-established rubrics and methods -- but on creativity and innovation, two things that don't always end up on paper.

A short, numbered list doesn't cover all the qualities of an effective principal -- a principal should have years of experience to complement the qualities I highlighted. In a release by Educators 4 Excellence, Evan Stone, Co-Founder and Co-CEO states, "As school leaders, principals play a key role in evaluating and supporting teachers and we need to make sure that they get fair and useful feedback that will ultimately benefit teachers and students." The bottom line is that in a school, everyone has a job to do, and everyone needs useful feedback in order to create the best learning environment possible. Principals are no exception.

Everybody, speak up! Share your thoughts on what makes a great principal, and how principals should be evaluated.

Wednesday, March 7, 2012

Mr. President: Improving the U.S. Education System Is Not a Competitive Sport

Imagine if before March Madness started, individual teams and athletes competed for additional pots of money. The winning applicants would receive extra funds to do things like hire more coaches or purchase cutting-edge training equipment. Would we think this was a system that was fair and beneficial to the quality of league play as a whole? Do we think the most deserving scholar athletes would benefit? Would we see it as a fair system for less-resourced colleges?

Of course not. Yet this is the kind of approach that the Obama Administration has taken with education. In no other area has the president striven harder to make his mark as a reformer by signaling that he is unafraid to shake up the education establishment, challenge old assumptions and dramatically step up the federal government's role as a catalyst for change. And if one area stands out as the hallmark of this approach, it's the emphasis on competitive grant programs rather than on programs that target the nation's least advantaged children.

Although the large majority of federal education dollars are still spent on formula-funded and other targeted programs, these programs have not captured the Administration's imagination or attention. Rather, acting more like a private foundation than a national government, the Administration has shown that its passion and budget priorities lie with competitive grant programs. The best-known examples are the U.S. Department of Education's various Race to the Top initiatives for K-12 education, the "First in the World" initiative for higher education programs and the competitions surrounding community colleges.

I certainly believe in the value of competition in getting the most out of people and have felt the thrill when my children, and now grandchildren, make the winning touchdown or bring home exceptional test results. But competition has its time and place, and what this Administration sees as a powerful lever to impose their ideas I view as a troubling trend that moves us away from the basic rule that the federal government's investment in education should be precisely targeted on assuring that all children have the opportunity to receive a quality education.

In accepting the Democratic nomination back in 2008, then-candidate Obama noted,

America, now is not the time for small plans. Now is the time to finally meet our moral obligation to provide every child a world-class education, because it will take nothing less to compete in the global economy.
I hope that moving forward, the President can recapture that sentiment and shift away from thinking about improving our education system as a competitive sport.

Arnold L. Mitchem, president of the Council for Opportunity in Education (COE) since its founding in 1986, has been a voice for low-income, first-generation students and individuals with disabilities his entire career. COE supports and advocates for federally funded TRIO Programs, which are the largest discretionary program in the U.S. Department of Education and now serve more than 872,000 students at 1,200 colleges and universities.

Monday, February 20, 2012

Tim King: With You When You're Right: The Anti-Deficit View of Black Male Achievement


Whenever my father passionately agrees with something I say, he shouts, "I'm with you when you're right!" After reading the recent report byShaun R. Harper, Director of the University of Pennsylvania's Center for the Study of Race & Equity in Education titled Black Male Student Success in Higher Education, I've come to see a deeper meaning in my father's catch-phrase. The report examines Black male college success in an effort to learn what works, what's right, and to then replicate those factors more broadly. Harper calls this an anti-deficit approach. I call it a change in focus that is long overdue.

Educators love to debate about whether targeted interventions can help at-risk populations, or if factors like poverty and being raised in a single parent household are too powerful to be overcome by schools alone. Some believe there is little to nothing that schools (K-12 as well as colleges) can do to prevent one third of Black men born this decade from spending time in prison; or to keep half of them from dropping-out of high school; or even to address that fact that just one in forty Black males will earn a bachelor's degree by the time they are twenty-five.

This view, however, is wrong. There is much and more that schools and colleges can do to boost high-school and college achievement levels for Black males, and we can start by changing our focus. When we speak solely of deficit-model statistics, we risk flattening the landscape and obscuring the successes of students who are able to achieve in spite of all of the obstacles facing Black males. We also risk perpetuating systems of inequality by turning observation into expectation. Ultimately, our conception about what it means to be a young Black male doesn't just limit our focus, it can limit that of our students as well. The innovation of Harper's research has been to turn this data upside down and, instead of asking what's wrong with the students who are failing, to ask what's right with the Black males who see success. According to many of the subjects of Harper's study, it was the first time anyone had bothered.

In interviewing 219 Black male "achievers" who were either attending or had graduated from college, Harper found the most common thread was that successful Black males are supported, both within their families and in their schools/communities, with relationships characterized by high expectations. Successful Black males often spoke of at least one extremely influential teacher who helped instill belief in their potential, whether or not the young men believed it themselves. These individuals, writes Harper, helped students seek out "educational resources to ensure their success -- tutoring and academic support programs, college preparatory initiatives, and summer academies and camps." According to Harper's study, these commitments to education were solidified in high school and college when Black males joined student organizations -- particularly when they took on leadership roles -- that anchored them to academic communities.

The idea that strong relationships impact student success shouldn't be anything new to educators. But the implication -- that race, background and gender are not destiny, and that focused interventions produce tangible results -- is enormous. Specifically, by taking an anti-deficit approach, we light the way towards discovering and implementing educational interventions targeted to meet the specific needs of Black male students. When the dominant presentation of Black males shows them dropping out of school and spending time in prison, students who might already be unsure of their place within an educational environment feel further pressure to follow the expectation and disengage. This isn't to say that we should ignore or sugar-coat the issues facing poor Black males today. But instead of fixating on these negative factors, we should balance them by holding up as examples young people who have successfully completed their education and earned degrees.

Perhaps the most remarkable finding in Harper's report is that the majority of the Black male graduates he interviewed stated that the biggest factor separating them from peers who didn't make it through college was serendipity. In other words, the achievers didn't view themselves as smarter, more persistent, harder working, or more economically advantaged than their friends back on the block. The achievers felt they were just lucky. Lucky to have people in their lives who were with them when they were right. Everyone should be so lucky. And, with the right kinds of schools, everyone can be.

Wednesday, February 15, 2012

Why We Must Listen to Young Black Males

Originally posted online at the Huffington Post at http://www.huffingtonpost.com/john-thompson/black-males-education_b_1263934.html by John Thompson
When my father died, only one group offered more heart-felt consolation than black female teenagers. The most emotional condolences came from my black male students and basketball buddies. Almost all of them volunteered their feelings about intense father-yearnings and often said they were watching for insights about the ways that intact families deal with suffering.

In Tracey and Abby Sparrow's "The Voices of Young Black Men," in Phi Delta Kappan, ten black males expressed feelings similar to those that thousands of my students have articulated. The Education Trust's Amy Wilkins, however, also used her family experiences as evidence to condemn the Sparrow's excellent piece.

No other organization has attacked teachers in a way than has upset me more than has the Education Trust. But, if for no other reason than respect for her father, Roger Wilkins, I will do my best to respond constructively. I believe, however, that Wilkins' attack on "The Voices of Young Black Men" illustrates how No Child Left Behind (NCLB), which embodied the Education Trust's faith in standardized testing and distrust of teachers, has caused extreme unintended damage to poor children of color.

The best way for Ms. Wilkins and other accountability hawks to help black males is to start listening to them. Teenagers' wisdom will confirm the social science which shows that kids learn from people who love them and the key to educational success is building trusting relationships.

NCLB has prompted an unflinching focus on the academic weaknesses of our most vulnerable and isolated children. Instead, we need to build on their strengths. As with other kids, among their greatest assets are profound emotional and moral consciousness, and a desire to communicate and contribute. Yes, I suspect the ten young men cited by the Sparrows were generous, perhaps to a fault, when saying their teachers were not to blame for the failure to undo toxic effects of peer pressure, but Deon, for instance, must have been honest in praising his teacher who took him in when he was kicked out of his home.

Rasean also has a point when claiming that it all comes down to his choices, "if I want to be in the streets, its me. If I want to get an education, its me." We need schools where a full diversity of the adult community can remind Rasean, however, that we are with him.

Damon adds, "if the people they (black males) hang out with are bad ... they stop doing good in school." After listening to hundreds of poor children of color describe themselves as "bad," I continue to hear them out and then reply that it pains me when the students I love describe themselves as "bad." Students, who tend to be their own harshest critics, need adults to help them inventory with much more precision the things that they do that are "good." I am haunted, however, by one such conversation where we discussed the student's belated understanding of his or her potential, but my young friend was stabbed to death an hour later.

Jovante offers the best single observation explaining why we need schools that foster profound conversations. The dropout explains, "If I could have been graded on my conversations and understanding, I would have been an excellent student. At first listen, Jovante sounds like he left school because of an inability to delay gratification. Part of his impatience, however, was due to seeing his mom struggle and he could not wait any longer before relieving part of her economic burden.

I have been privileged to participate in hundreds of conversations with black males that were inspired by Roger Wilkins' wisdom, as expressed in PBS documentaries. Whether I was teaching Black History or Government, I tried to use Roger Wilkins, who contributed so much wisdom to that amazing programming, as a virtual co-instructor. Type "Roger Wilkins" into the PBS web site's search engine, and 5570 links appear. But, in my experience, data-driven accountability has driven most of those types of engaging lessons from inner city classrooms. If it is "not on the test," it is not taught anymore. Teachers are under the bubble-in testing gun and pressured to do non-stop test prep, and not allowed to deviate from their paced, teacher-proof pacing mandates and, thus, we cannot attempt lessons that the students love.

And that brings me back to my complaint with Ms. Wilkins and the Education Trust. She cites seven friends and family members as sources, but complains about an article that cited ten voices. Her organization, however, cites a tiny number of schools that "beat the odds" and combined standardized testing with engaging and respectful instruction. They should listen to the vast majority of inner city teachers and our students who recount the humiliations imposed upon us by test-driven accountability. We can explain why education is primarily an affair of "the Heart," not "the Head." Education must be a conversation. Yes, we must debate the things that we see as wrong with our opponents, but we need our primary focus to be building on what is right with our kids.

GO HERE TO READ COMMENTS ASSOCIATED WITH THIS POST.

Tuesday, February 14, 2012

Michael J. Petrilli: ESEA Waivers: Are They Worth the Trouble?

Published in the Huffington Post at http://www.huffingtonpost.com/michael-j-petrilli/nclb-waivers_b_1273752.html

With a week to go until the February 21 deadline for the second round of Secretary Duncan's ESEA Waiverpalooza, states nationwide are studying the results of round one to figure out what federal officials did -- and didn't -- approve. And they are asking themselves a question: Is it even worth it? (A few states -- including California and Pennsylvania have already decided: No.)

In the end, I suspect that most of the 28 states that have indicated an interest in a waiver will file for one, if only because, by this point, they've already sunk thousands of man-hours and tens of thousands of dollars into the process. And some of the flexibility provided by the feds to the first 10 approved states is for real -- getting rid of the "100 percent proficient by 2014" deadline; allowing all Title I schools to spend their dollars in a "schoolwide" manner; eliminating the ill-designed supplemental services program; ending the "highly qualified teachers" mandate.

But what about the accountability policies at the heart of No Child Left Behind? Just how much leeway did the administration actually provide? Let's consider three big problems with current law, and whether the waiver process fixed them.

Problem #1: A vision of "improvement" that looks at how this year's cohort compares to last year's, rather than individual student growth over time.

A few leading states -- I'm thinking of Colorado especially -- have leapfrogged several generations by focusing on the performance trajectories of individual students, rather than looking at different cohorts of kids over time. In the Colorado system, the goal is for schools to put their students on a course to be college and career ready by the end of high school. That creates strong incentives for schools to accelerate the progress of kids who are far behind, while paying attention to kids at the middle and top of the performance spectrum, too. This makes perfect sense, right?

Not according to the bean counters on Maryland Avenue. They insisted that Colorado add to its system of annual targets for getting a certain number of students to "proficiency" -- with the expectation that an increasing number of kids would reach that target every year.

But that's Accountability 1.0 thinking. Why do we care about how this year's fourth graders perform versus last year's fourth graders? Or whether more fourth graders reached "proficient?" What matters is whether kids are on track for college and career readiness -- and whether students make enough progress over the school year to get them onto this trajectory. At least in the Colorado case, the feds have taken an elegant and rational system and made it more complicated and convoluted.

Problem #2: A race-based system of school accountability.

No Child Left Behind played a critical role in exposing the achievement gaps that plague so many of our schools. Continuing to demand transparency around subgroup performance makes eminent sense. But requiring that accountability systems be explicitly race-based is problematic, especially as the conception of "race" continues to change and an increasing number of students view themselves as multiracial. Furthermore, policies that encourage schools to literally "narrow the gap" enshrine in public policy the notion that we are rooting for white, Asian, and affluent students to do worse, or at least do no better. This is nuts. Yet if anything, the waiver process has exacerbated this problem.

Back to Colorado. Its focus on individual performance mitigates the need for subgroups because it creates strong incentives for schools to focus on their lowest achievers, many of whom belong to one or more of the various subgroups. (These kids generally have to make a LOT of progress to be on track for college and career readiness.) But that wasn't enough for the department; Uncle Sam wanted subgroup accountability, too.

Or consider Florida. Its longstanding accountability system includes a weight for the growth of a school's lowest performing quartile. This excellent provision is another way to pressure schools to pay attention to their educationally neediest kids. So how did this system fare with federal officials? Not well. The same bean-counters (or peer reviewers, or both, it's hard to be sure) demanded that Florida promise to intervene in schools that get positive school ratings -- As and Bs even -- if one or more of their subgroups isn't up to par. But they can only get As or Bs if their low performing students are making strong progress. Bottom line: Florida got overruled.

Problem #3: Labeling everyone a failure means nobody's a failure.

Probably the biggest complaint about No Child Left Behind was that it over-identified schools and districts as failing, meaning that the very worst institutions -- the full-blown dropout factories --got lost in the mix. So one goal of the waiver process is to bring the number of failing schools down to a more realistic number, right?

Then try to explain the feds' reaction to Tennessee's proposal. In its explanation of the changes that Tennessee made to its original proposal, the Department of Education boasted that "based on data from the 2010-2011 school year, 105 of 135 districts would be identified." And this is a good thing?

The feds also bragged that Minnesota agreed (under pressure, one assumes) to drop the "safe harbor" provision from its accountability system -- meaning schools that have low proficiency rates but are making great progress will no longer escape the "failing schools" label. What's the point of that?

So again, is "flexibility" worth it? For states hoping to adopt next-generation accountability systems -- those that move beyond the poor design choices of No Child Left Behind -- the answer appears to be no. But hey, getting rid of the highly qualified teachers mandate is nice.

Originally published on the Fordham Institute's Flypaper blog.

for comments on this article go HERE.

Saturday, February 4, 2012

Parents Upset Over Bilingual School's Closure- this could be DC....


This story has been corrected and updated.

Several days before Detroit Public Schools Emergency Manager Roy Roberts is set to officially announce district-wide school closings, he spoke with parents and teachers in a packed gymnasium at Maybury Elementary in Southwest Detroit Friday afternoon to confirm the school will close after the current school year.

The bilingual school provides instruction to just under 400 students. It lost about 200 students due a consolidation last year that moved fourth and fifth grades to the nearby, newly opened Amelia Earhart Elementary Middle School.

More than 80 percent of Maybury's students are Hispanic or Latino, and Principal Ellen Snedeker said a high percentage of students speak only Spanish.

"It's a school where [students] come in speaking mono-lingual Spanish and are actually taught in Spanish," she said. "We use the skills in their first language to introduce them into English."

Despite the linguistic challenge, Snedeker said, Maybury is a high-achieving school. And she worries about the impact its closing might have on Southwest Detroit's Latino population.

"The problem is that the school is not only a building, but it's really a community center," Snedeker said. "By breaking it up, they're really destroying the community center."

Monica Parga, whose five-year-old son, Jorge, goes to Maybury, said she found the school's closing extremely upsetting. She said Roberts gave a brief presentation Friday but she felt he didn't adequately respond to parents' concerns.

"My thoughts are they're making a very, very, very huge mistake," Parga said. "They're sending us to Neinas. Neinas has failed all their annual yearly progress reports. Maybury has met the standards every single year."

Neinas Elementary, located approximately one mile from Maybury, has failed its Adequate Yearly Progress report, an accountability measure defined by the No Child Left Behind Act, the last three years. Maybury has met AYP in the previous two years.

Snedeker said once Maybury closes, students will be dispersed to three different locations: Amelia Earhart Elementary and Middle School, Neinas Elementary and Beard Elementary School. According to Snedeker, the district decided to close Maybury because of its close proximity to Amelia Earhart.

UPDATE: 1:30 p.m. -- Detroit Public Schools spokeswoman Jennifer Mrozowski released a statement from Roberts in response to this report that Maybury would close:

"Parents deserve to know well in advance-in this case, much earlier than in the past-the changes planned for their children's school, in order to be prepared. This year's process is specifically designed to share all of this information early, and comprehensively, and to follow that with informational programs and enrollment and application opportunities.

We are announcing a comprehensive transformation for Detroit Public Schools aimed at improving academics for all students. The EAA [Educational Achievement Authority] will include dynamic new approaches to teaching and learning that Dr. [John] Covington will be introducing next week.

DPS plans to close, consolidate and merge schools that are under-capacity to create a more efficient system of high-performing schools and drive more resources to those facilities and their students.

We will err on the side of over communicating and, where we don't have all the answers in place yet, we will commit to responding to parents promptly."

On Feb. 9, DPS will officially announce the list of schools to be closed as well as some that will be handed over to charter operators. TheFree Press reports Roberts has spoken about closures at several others schools in the district ahead of his announcement, including nearby Southwestern High School.

CORRECTION: An earlier version of this story incorrectly reported that Roberts arrived at Maybury Elementary with 10 bodyguards. That statement has been excised from this version and The Huffington Post regrets the error.
got to site of origin by clicking HERE.

Monday, January 30, 2012

Why the Education State of the Union Matters




Posted in the Huffington Post : 01/29/2012 6:25 pm

(Or, A Tale of Two Speeches)

Over at Teacher in a Strange Land, Nancy Flanagan asked, ""Who speaks for public education?"

I'd answer that a lot of people do (for better, and for worse) but we don't all get the same kind of microphone, or the same airtime.

After watching the State of the Union address Tuesday night, I found myself thinking about the differences between President Obama's statements on education and those of California Governor Jerry Brown.

In public statements over the past year, Governor Brown has said what many educators and parents nationwide have been saying for over a decade: that current state and federal education policy has emphasized high-stakes testing so much it has distorted and undermined the learning process. And in his address, he outlined a specific direction for policymakers: that the amount of standardized testing be reduced, that the data be returned to schools more quickly and that more qualitative measures of school performance be developed and used. He ended his education remarks with these words:

The house of education is divided by powerful forces and strong emotions. My role as governor is not to choose sides but to listen, to engage and to lead. I will do that. I embrace both reform and tradition -- not complacency. My hunch is that principals and teachers know the most, but I'll take good ideas from wherever they come.
By contrast, in the State of the Union Tuesday night, President Obama made vague allusions to a few existing K-12 education policies. They include paying teachers to increase test scores ("merit" pay) and encouraging states to seek 'waivers' that exchange freedom from NCLB's impossible requirements for the adoption of the Administration's preferred policies, which are just as strict. Hidden in applause lines aboutrewarding the best teachers and granting flexibility are unproven policies that many researchers and public school stakeholders agree are hurting education.

But, some ask, why does this matter? Neither of these leaders have any direct say over what happens in classrooms. Speaking strictly literally, school systems are typically run by local district officials and school board members (or mayoral appointees... ) overseeing schools, principals and teachers. So why should we care what a president, or even a governor, says or does about schools?

Because aside from the influence and funding at their disposal, their policy advocacy shapes public perceptions of public education, and those perceptions shape our behavior. (They have bigger microphones, and better airtime.)

It pains me to say this, but it's the truth: Most people have no clue what goes on in their local government. Everyone knows who the president is; most people know who their governor is. But how many people can even name their representatives on their town council or school board without a Google search? Of them, how many know what their policy positions are, or how they've voted to spend their neighbors' property taxes? (Answer: Not a whole lot.)

As I talked to Denver voters during our local school board races last fall, it was clear that -- exceptionally involved community members excluded -- most voters were taking their cues on how to vote from what they'd heard about education in the national media. (This is why it's possible for the majority of people toapprove of their local schools and teachers, but believe that public education as a whole is failing.)

So when a governor says he believes principals and teachers know the most about education, and asks for policies that reemphasize teaching and learning instead of testing, that matters. And when a president says he wants teachers to teach with creativity and passion, but uses the influence of the federal government to increase high-stakes testing, that matters too.

For starters, voters who consistently hear positive messages about how schools should be funded, and teachers trusted, are probably going to be more inclined to support policies that fund schools and empower teachers. And when under-informed voters hear misleading statements about "merit" and "flexibility," they're being set up to support policies, at all levels of government, that will hurt schools instead of helping them.

Moreover, when the most powerful and visible leaders promote a vision of schooling that works from the bottom up, they empower the local actors who do the work to do what they think is best. But when those leaders deceive the public, and position themselves as the grantors of "flexibility" and the arbiters of "merit," local stakeholders get stuck dealing with inappropriate (and just plain bad) policy, which can create some pretty toxic circumstances where the rubber meets the road.

Of course, we shouldn't (as one Tweeter accused) "blame the POTUS" entirely for bad things happening in our local schools, nor should we give a governor undue credit if and when his state's schools improve. But high-profile leaders wield a disproportionate amount of power over the circumstances under which public school stakeholders work. And we have every right to demand that they wield that power responsibly.

Follow Sabrina Stevens Shupe on Twitter: www.twitter.com/TeacherSabrina