Showing posts with label NLCB waiver. Show all posts
Showing posts with label NLCB waiver. Show all posts

Tuesday, February 14, 2012

Michael J. Petrilli: ESEA Waivers: Are They Worth the Trouble?

Published in the Huffington Post at http://www.huffingtonpost.com/michael-j-petrilli/nclb-waivers_b_1273752.html

With a week to go until the February 21 deadline for the second round of Secretary Duncan's ESEA Waiverpalooza, states nationwide are studying the results of round one to figure out what federal officials did -- and didn't -- approve. And they are asking themselves a question: Is it even worth it? (A few states -- including California and Pennsylvania have already decided: No.)

In the end, I suspect that most of the 28 states that have indicated an interest in a waiver will file for one, if only because, by this point, they've already sunk thousands of man-hours and tens of thousands of dollars into the process. And some of the flexibility provided by the feds to the first 10 approved states is for real -- getting rid of the "100 percent proficient by 2014" deadline; allowing all Title I schools to spend their dollars in a "schoolwide" manner; eliminating the ill-designed supplemental services program; ending the "highly qualified teachers" mandate.

But what about the accountability policies at the heart of No Child Left Behind? Just how much leeway did the administration actually provide? Let's consider three big problems with current law, and whether the waiver process fixed them.

Problem #1: A vision of "improvement" that looks at how this year's cohort compares to last year's, rather than individual student growth over time.

A few leading states -- I'm thinking of Colorado especially -- have leapfrogged several generations by focusing on the performance trajectories of individual students, rather than looking at different cohorts of kids over time. In the Colorado system, the goal is for schools to put their students on a course to be college and career ready by the end of high school. That creates strong incentives for schools to accelerate the progress of kids who are far behind, while paying attention to kids at the middle and top of the performance spectrum, too. This makes perfect sense, right?

Not according to the bean counters on Maryland Avenue. They insisted that Colorado add to its system of annual targets for getting a certain number of students to "proficiency" -- with the expectation that an increasing number of kids would reach that target every year.

But that's Accountability 1.0 thinking. Why do we care about how this year's fourth graders perform versus last year's fourth graders? Or whether more fourth graders reached "proficient?" What matters is whether kids are on track for college and career readiness -- and whether students make enough progress over the school year to get them onto this trajectory. At least in the Colorado case, the feds have taken an elegant and rational system and made it more complicated and convoluted.

Problem #2: A race-based system of school accountability.

No Child Left Behind played a critical role in exposing the achievement gaps that plague so many of our schools. Continuing to demand transparency around subgroup performance makes eminent sense. But requiring that accountability systems be explicitly race-based is problematic, especially as the conception of "race" continues to change and an increasing number of students view themselves as multiracial. Furthermore, policies that encourage schools to literally "narrow the gap" enshrine in public policy the notion that we are rooting for white, Asian, and affluent students to do worse, or at least do no better. This is nuts. Yet if anything, the waiver process has exacerbated this problem.

Back to Colorado. Its focus on individual performance mitigates the need for subgroups because it creates strong incentives for schools to focus on their lowest achievers, many of whom belong to one or more of the various subgroups. (These kids generally have to make a LOT of progress to be on track for college and career readiness.) But that wasn't enough for the department; Uncle Sam wanted subgroup accountability, too.

Or consider Florida. Its longstanding accountability system includes a weight for the growth of a school's lowest performing quartile. This excellent provision is another way to pressure schools to pay attention to their educationally neediest kids. So how did this system fare with federal officials? Not well. The same bean-counters (or peer reviewers, or both, it's hard to be sure) demanded that Florida promise to intervene in schools that get positive school ratings -- As and Bs even -- if one or more of their subgroups isn't up to par. But they can only get As or Bs if their low performing students are making strong progress. Bottom line: Florida got overruled.

Problem #3: Labeling everyone a failure means nobody's a failure.

Probably the biggest complaint about No Child Left Behind was that it over-identified schools and districts as failing, meaning that the very worst institutions -- the full-blown dropout factories --got lost in the mix. So one goal of the waiver process is to bring the number of failing schools down to a more realistic number, right?

Then try to explain the feds' reaction to Tennessee's proposal. In its explanation of the changes that Tennessee made to its original proposal, the Department of Education boasted that "based on data from the 2010-2011 school year, 105 of 135 districts would be identified." And this is a good thing?

The feds also bragged that Minnesota agreed (under pressure, one assumes) to drop the "safe harbor" provision from its accountability system -- meaning schools that have low proficiency rates but are making great progress will no longer escape the "failing schools" label. What's the point of that?

So again, is "flexibility" worth it? For states hoping to adopt next-generation accountability systems -- those that move beyond the poor design choices of No Child Left Behind -- the answer appears to be no. But hey, getting rid of the highly qualified teachers mandate is nice.

Originally published on the Fordham Institute's Flypaper blog.

for comments on this article go HERE.

Interview with Diane Ravitch: California's Rejection of NCLB Waivers Sends a Message

By Anthony Cody on November 29, 2011 11:53 AM

California, with more public school students than any other state, has surprised many by declining to apply for waivers to No Child Left Behind. The implications of this decision are far-reaching, and so in the coming weeks I am going to be asking a variety of educational leaders for their thoughts. Today, I am sharing the thoughts of education historian Diane Ravitch.diane_cover.jpg


What do you think of the decision by elected leaders in California to forgo the opportunity to apply for waivers to NCLB?

I was very pleased when California decided to turn down the waivers for California. I think it took a lot of courage by Governor Brown and Superintendent Torlakson.

What do you think the down side of applying for these waivers would have been?

One of the many problems with NCLB is that it came packaged with unrealistic, expensive and heavy-handed federal mandates. It put too much emphasis on testing and punishment for failure to reach impossible goals. The waivers now offered by the US Department of Education require the states to comply with other mandates, still tied to the NCLB-style accountability framework. The emphasis on testing under the waiver plan is as heavy-handed as it has been under NCLB. Many schools with high numbers of low-scoring students will be subject to firings and closings. They need help, not punishment. One of the lessons of NCLB is that the federal government does not know how to improve schools.

What do you think will be the result of this decision? How will schools in the state cope with NCLB if it remains in effect?

NCLB is a terrible, punitive, ineffective law. The law mandates that 100% of all students must be proficient in math and reading by 2014. No state is even close to that goal. More than 80% of public schools in the United States are currently "failing," by the law's requirements. Congress should scrap the accountability provisions and start over. The waivers ease the pressure for change. Every citizen in every community, town, and citizen should be calling their Congressman and Senators and urging them to get rid of this crazy law. No other nation in the world ever created a system that was guaranteed to label almost every school in the nation a failure.

Many states and districts made big promises to get Race to the Top grants. How is that working out for them?

To get Race to the Top money, states had to promise to open more privately managed charter schools and to tie teacher evaluation to student test scores, among other things. Research consistently shows that charters vary widely in quality; some are very good, some are mediocre, some are bad. Teacher evaluation by test scores is very controversial, and there is no evidence as yet that it leads to higher test scores. For sure, it will raise the stakes on testing. Since most teachers don't teach tested subjects, some states are creating more tests, and others are still trying to figure out how to evaluate those teachers without standardized scores. In New York, several hundred principals signed a petition against the state's new evaluation system, on grounds that it was untried and would demoralize their staff.

Assuming California now charts a new path for school reform, what do you think that should look like?

California is in the midst of the worst fiscal situation in modern times. The state must change the way it finances schools and universities, so that resources are available to restore what was once of the best education systems in the nation. The leadership for school reform should come from Sacramento and from local communities, from people who understand local problems. Washington should send federal dollars to help educate the students with the greatest needs--those with disabilities, those who are poor, and those who are English language learners. That is the proper role of the federal government.

How do you think this stance might influence other states across the country?

If California could send a message to other states, it should be this: There are no easy answers, no quick fixes, no solutions that can be supplied by Washington. We are all involved in the job of school improvement--parents, students, teachers, administrators, the local community. We must work together to raise up the next generation, to make sure they are healthy and prepared for good lives as citizens of our society. Our public schools are and will continue to be a vital part of our democratic society. We must improve the schools by making sure that every child in every community has a full and balanced curriculum. We must require that every school has an arts program and physical education. Our future as a state and nation depends on the education we provide today.

On January 20, the Sacramento Coalition to Save Public Education is sponsoring An Evening with Diane Ravitch, who will be joined onstage by Superintendent Tom Torlakson, Linda Darling-Hammond and myself. Please join us!


What do you think of Diane Ravitch's viewpoint? Should other states follow California's lead and leave the NCLB waivers behind?

Follow me on Twitter at @AnthonyCody
image of Diane Ravitch used by permission.

REad more and all the comments by clicking here.